What Do We Do If a Microsoft 365 Account Is Compromised?

By Dane Gray, 24uNet. Last reviewed November 11, 2026.
Short answer: If a Microsoft 365 account is compromised, a password reset alone is not enough. The attacker can keep an open session, and may have added a device, an MFA method, a hidden inbox rule, or an app. Block new sign-ins, end every session, reset the password and MFA, remove anything you don't recognize, then check mail rules and sent mail.
How can you tell a Microsoft 365 account is compromised?
Any one of these is a reason to act, even if the person still has MFA enabled:
MFA prompts nobody started, or a password that suddenly stops working
Mail in Sent or Deleted that nobody on the team wrote, including payment or "send money" messages
Mail you expected is missing, or a client says they replied and you never saw it
An inbox rule or forwarding setting you didn't create
A new device, a new MFA method, or a sign-in from a place or time that doesn't fit
Microsoft's guide to a compromised email account lists the same kinds of signs, including rules that bury mail in Notes, Junk, or RSS folders, and unexpected external forwarding.
Why isn't a password reset enough?
A password change stops the attacker from signing in again with the old password. It does not always end a session that is already open, and it does not remove the extra access an attacker often adds: a device registered to the account, their own MFA method, a hidden inbox rule, or an app with mailbox access.
The cleanup order, and why the session has to be ended with the password change, is in why a password reset isn't enough.
What's the checklist, in order?
If you already have an IT provider, call them first and walk through this together. Write down what you find before you change it. Several of these steps need an administrator. If you can't block sign-in or end every session yourself, start with the mailbox checks and call your provider.
This order matches the first steps on 24uNet's Microsoft 365 account takeover page, and Microsoft's recovery steps.
1. Block new sign-ins for the account.
Microsoft prefers that the account be disabled while you investigate, so the attacker cannot return. If you can't disable it, reset the password as a next-best step, and don't send the new password by email to that same mailbox. Your IT provider should do this.
2. End every active session.
Sign the account out everywhere. This cuts off a stolen session that would otherwise keep working after a password change.
3. Reset the password and set up MFA again.
Use a new, strong password. Review every MFA method on the account, and remove any phone, app, or key you don't recognize. Then enroll MFA again for the real user.
4. Remove devices you don't recognize.
Attackers often register their own device so they can return later. Remove anything that isn't a company phone or computer you can identify.
5. Check inbox rules and forwarding, and write down where mail was going.
Look at mailbox rules and the forwarding setting. A rule you didn't create, especially one that forwards mail outside the company, deletes messages, or files them in a folder nobody uses, is a sign someone else was in the mailbox. Don't only delete the rule; note the destination, because that is evidence. How to check for hidden inbox rules walks through both places in Outlook.
6. Review apps that have access to the account.
An attacker may have granted an app permission to read or send mail. Remove consents you don't recognize, and have your provider review them across the company.
7. Review recent sign-ins, sent mail, and deleted mail.
Look at sign-in activity, Sent Items, Deleted Items, and Recoverable Items. Note anything the real user didn't send, and the recipients. This is how you learn whether a payment request or a client file left the mailbox.
8. Tell your IT or security provider, and your cyber insurer, early.
Don't wait until the mailbox looks fixed. If money or client data may be involved, your insurer, and your attorney if you work with one, will want a timeline. For the rest of that first hour, read the first hour of a cyberattack.
What should your IT provider check that you cannot?
An owner can check their own Outlook rules, forwarding, and sent mail. An administrator should also:
Confirm every session was revoked, not only a password change
Review MFA methods and registered devices in Entra ID, which is Microsoft 365's directory
Review app consents and any admin roles on the account
Check whether other mailboxes have new rules or forwarding
Pull the audit log for sign-ins, rule changes, and mail that was sent or deleted
Point them at Microsoft's recovery steps if they need the technical procedure.
The account already had MFA. How did the takeover happen?
MFA still stops a large share of password attacks, and you should keep it enabled. It does not stop every takeover. Attackers can steal a session after a real MFA prompt, trick someone into approving a sign-in on Microsoft's own page, or flood a phone with prompts until someone taps Approve. Why MFA isn't enough explains those three paths, and what closes the gap.
How does 24uNet help?
This checklist is what to do once you already suspect a compromise. The better outcome is catching it at 2am, before a fraudulent payment request goes out.
ITDR (identity threat detection and response) watches Microsoft 365 sign-ins, sessions, mailbox rules, and app consents for signs of takeover. On clear-cut cases it contains the account automatically, day or night: sessions are ended, hidden inbox rules and forwarding are disabled, sign-in is blocked, and the password and MFA are reset. Cases that need judgment go to analysts, and you get a written timeline of what was touched.
ITDR is included in BusinessCare. If you want to see what's already happening in your Microsoft 365 tenant, book your $299 BusinessCare Walkthrough.
FAQ
What do we do if a Microsoft 365 account is compromised?
A password reset alone is usually not enough. Block new sign-ins, end every session, reset the password and MFA, remove devices, methods, rules, and apps you don't recognize, then check sent and deleted mail. Tell your IT provider early.
Does a password reset remove an attacker from Microsoft 365?
Not by itself. End every session at the same time, then remove devices, MFA methods, inbox rules, forwarding, and apps you don't recognize.
How do I check for hidden inbox rules?
In Outlook on the web, open Settings, then Mail, then Rules, and also check Forwarding. Any rule you didn't create is a reason to call your IT provider. The full walkthrough is in how to check for hidden inbox rules.
Can a Microsoft 365 account be taken over when MFA is enabled?
Yes. MFA does not stop a stolen session or a sign-in the user was tricked into approving. That's why the checklist treats sessions, devices, and rules as part of the cleanup, not only the password.
What is ITDR?
Identity threat detection and response. It watches what a Microsoft 365 account does after sign-in, and contains a takeover when behavior turns hostile. 24uNet's ITDR page explains how that works.
Next step
If you think an account is already compromised, work the checklist and tell your provider now. If you want someone watching those signs after hours, see how 24uNet detects and contains Microsoft 365 account takeovers.




Comments